Latest Movie Hotties Headlines

Face Off: Scarlett Johansson vs. Jennifer Lawrence

10.07.2013by: Droz

Ya'll seemed to like the geeks more than the sluts, based on the results of last week's Face Off. Me, I'd say a nice blend of each would be ideal. The best of both worlds. That's usually the best way to go, if you can find it.

There are a number of reasons to compare Scarlett Johansson with Jennifer Lawrence. They're two hotties with a great many things in common. These are currently two of the hottest women in the Marvel movie franchises, playing Black Widow in The Avengers movies and Mystique in the X-men movies. They're two of the most celebrated actresses in all of Hollywood, making big waves and big bank. They both made their big time debut in red hot dresses at the Oscars. They're both blondes (usually), both curvaceous, both desired by millions the world over and they've got a ton of high profile movies coming out in the next year or so. The only problem now is trying to decide between them. So how the hell does one choose between two such powerhouse hotties? We shall see.

Beauty

One could make a big, long list of all the things to love about Scarlett. High up on that list would be her beautiful face. She's not your traditional beauty in many respects, but that's not a bad thing. With those full lips and big, doe eyes, she's got the goods to become instantly lovable. And when she cries and those big eyes well up and become pained, that's like an arrow right to the heart of a guy. I'd love to be the guy who gets to console Scarlett in her time of need.

I feel guilty every time the subject of Jennifer's looks come up. It's not like I'm on the fence about her. 95% of the time I find her a stone cold knock out. It's that niggling 5% that messes with my head. A lot of times it's not even her fault. Sometimes they do unflattering shit with her make up or just present her in a way that's less than flattering. Then again, they do that with all the hotties from time to time. The thing with Jen is that she's not afraid to get a little dirty or go minimal with the make-up when the situation calls for it. Unfortunately that tends to hurt her in the Beauty category, but it is the sign of a great actress who doesn't always care about the superficial. You have to admire that.

Body

Things have changed over the years as far as Scarlett's body goes. It's speculation, but to me it seems like her gifts up top went away to a significant degree. It's possible she had some old implants removed. There's also the more distressing possibility that she had a breast reduction. I don't know for sure. All I know is that there appears to be less of her there now than there used to be. That being said, she's still got one of the finest asses in the world and a lovely, curvaceous body. Those titties were indeed epic, but there's still plenty left to enjoy on Scarlett.

Nothing out of place or missing on Jennifer's body - quite the contrary. She's just how I would have any woman be. What's even more impressive is that she keeps herself looking this hot without resorting to the bullshit other celebs use to stay fit. Jen recently spoke on the matter, advising anyone who tells her to get on a diet to "go f*ck yourself" as she so eloquently put it. As Jennifer sums it up, "Id rather look chubby on screen and like a person in real life." Amen.

Hotness

Wait, what are you saying, Droz? That Scarlett isn't hot? Heh, silly person. We all know Scarlett has produced lava-like levels of hotness for almost a decade now. But if we're talking about the whole package, both inside and out, I've got to put Scarlett in a second place position to Jennifer. See my reasoning for that to the right.

Hotness can be assessed in different ways. There's your external hotness that consists of one's body, what it looks like and how one chooses to show it off. Then you have what comes from inside and how that makes a person all the more attractive. That's probably the most potent of all hotness qualities and it's the thing that makes Jennifer the hottest to me. She's just so down to earth. There's no nonsense about her, no pretense, no bullshit. She's genuine, generous and totally unmoved by the trappings of celebrity. I find that intoxicating, perhaps even more so than her looks, because you don't see it very often in celebrity circles.

Career

Scarlett has had a fantastic career already and promises to continue in that fashion for years to come. However, there are Hollywood skills and then there are the skilled in Hollywood. Scarlett makes a ton of money and appears in lots of big movies. I'm not sure if she could stand toe to toe with Jennifer in any kind of thespian throw down though. She's a decent actress and occasionally a really good one, but Jennifer is poised to be one of the great ones.

At some point they'll begin looking for a new Meryl Streep for the 21st century (as soon as Meryl herself is done being that). It wouldn't surprise me at all if Jennifer is the one to whom they turn to fill that position. With an Oscar at 22 and more a virtual certainty to come in the near future, they'll surely be devoting chapters to her in future movie history books. I'd call that a lock for a Career category win.

Jennifer

Not an easy call to make here, but I'm going with Jenny due mostly to her superior acting cred. On looks alone, I'm pretty sure these two are evenly matched.

Just one man's opinion. What are your thoughts?
EXPRESS THEM BELOW!!

RECOMMENDED MOVIE NEWS

Drool Back
Not registered? Sign-up!
Or

6:16PM on 10/09/2013
JLaw all day although Scarlett is awesome. Isn't this whole face-off thing kind of pervy though?

You should do a versus of most badass characters just to balance things out.
JLaw all day although Scarlett is awesome. Isn't this whole face-off thing kind of pervy though?

You should do a versus of most badass characters just to balance things out.
Your Reply:



2:52PM on 10/09/2013

jennifer. scarlet's piggie nose and dumb-ass real life bs makes her ugly.

and jen is still incredibly sexy, regardless.
and jen is still incredibly sexy, regardless.
Your Reply:



+3
5:23PM on 10/08/2013

Tough decision

This one is extremely close and it's really tough to decide. They're both extremely hot; great matchup. But I'm going to say Johansson, because I've really liked her for a while now. That was the only thing that could break the tie in my mind.
This one is extremely close and it's really tough to decide. They're both extremely hot; great matchup. But I'm going to say Johansson, because I've really liked her for a while now. That was the only thing that could break the tie in my mind.
Your Reply:



+5
3:58PM on 10/08/2013

Scarlett.

I really like Jennifer too, but between these two it has to go to Scarlett in every category. I like them both though, so still digging the hottie.
I really like Jennifer too, but between these two it has to go to Scarlett in every category. I like them both though, so still digging the hottie.
Your Reply:



3:02PM on 10/08/2013

Scarlett wins... No contest!

I don't know how Jennifer Lawrence was given a tie for body. Unless you are counting the fact that she has a physical structure below her neck, then Scarlett takes that category. And we can't really say Jennifer is down to earth at this point in her career. Many actors and actresses start their careers as down to earth people and get turned by the Hollywood lifestyle. At worst, Scarlett deserves a tie in this category. I will agree with the other categories, but Scarlett still has this one.
I don't know how Jennifer Lawrence was given a tie for body. Unless you are counting the fact that she has a physical structure below her neck, then Scarlett takes that category. And we can't really say Jennifer is down to earth at this point in her career. Many actors and actresses start their careers as down to earth people and get turned by the Hollywood lifestyle. At worst, Scarlett deserves a tie in this category. I will agree with the other categories, but Scarlett still has this one.
Your Reply:



+5
12:56PM on 10/08/2013

tough choice...

But I've gotta go with Scarlett Johansson on this one.
But I've gotta go with Scarlett Johansson on this one.
Your Reply:



+1
6:53AM on 10/08/2013

You know... I see this ending in a tie, myself.

I think you called this one all wrong... I do love Jennifer Lawrence. I really do. She's hot, she's cool, she's a great actress... But I think your rating's here are a bit off. The way I see it:
Beauty = Tie
Body = Tie
Hotness = Scarlett
Career = Jennifer

The only way I could see Jennifer pulling this one is if you had a spot for personality, because while Scarlett seems like she may be an okay chick, Jennifer's seems more down to earth, and has a girl next door quality that makes her
I think you called this one all wrong... I do love Jennifer Lawrence. I really do. She's hot, she's cool, she's a great actress... But I think your rating's here are a bit off. The way I see it:
Beauty = Tie
Body = Tie
Hotness = Scarlett
Career = Jennifer

The only way I could see Jennifer pulling this one is if you had a spot for personality, because while Scarlett seems like she may be an okay chick, Jennifer's seems more down to earth, and has a girl next door quality that makes her even more attractive... But since you don't take into account personality here, I think you gotta call this one a tie.
Your Reply:



5:22AM on 10/08/2013

Completely wrong here !!

just about ask anyone in the planet and 95% of them will say it's Scarlett !
just about ask anyone in the planet and 95% of them will say it's Scarlett !
Your Reply:



11:22PM on 10/07/2013

Damn Why you gotta go and do this to me?

Two of the best in the business any way you look at it. If I had to choose I would say Lawrence has a better personality but there is no way I could be made to choose which one is hotter.
Two of the best in the business any way you look at it. If I had to choose I would say Lawrence has a better personality but there is no way I could be made to choose which one is hotter.
Your Reply:



10:34PM on 10/07/2013

I'm inclined to call this a tie

Yes, JLaw has the big franchise and the Oscar while ScarJo just has the big franchise. I think ScarJo is a better actress than people give her credit for: she kills it in DON JON. But yes, Jennifer is a great actress.

Looks-wise, I've seen some odd pics of Jennifer while Scarlett has never been anything less than stunning.
Yes, JLaw has the big franchise and the Oscar while ScarJo just has the big franchise. I think ScarJo is a better actress than people give her credit for: she kills it in DON JON. But yes, Jennifer is a great actress.

Looks-wise, I've seen some odd pics of Jennifer while Scarlett has never been anything less than stunning.
Your Reply:



10:27PM on 10/07/2013

I like Jennifer and all but...

We're talking about Scarlett Johansson. One of the most beautiful women of all time.

Looks aside though, Jennifer has an Oscar but Scarlett's career as a whole?... Right now on October 7th, 2013? It's obviously better.
We're talking about Scarlett Johansson. One of the most beautiful women of all time.

Looks aside though, Jennifer has an Oscar but Scarlett's career as a whole?... Right now on October 7th, 2013? It's obviously better.
Your Reply:



1:51PM on 10/07/2013

Wrong

No way, Jennifer is very pretty but Scarlett is a freaking goddess who easily beats her in both the body and face categories.
No way, Jennifer is very pretty but Scarlett is a freaking goddess who easily beats her in both the body and face categories.
Your Reply:



1:49PM on 10/07/2013

Jennifer Lawrence

ScarJo is definitely a beautiful woman and a great actress, but Jennifer Lawrence wins this very easily for me.
ScarJo is definitely a beautiful woman and a great actress, but Jennifer Lawrence wins this very easily for me.
Your Reply:



12:44PM on 10/07/2013

lmao

Yeah, right!

Checks to the left.
Yeah, right!

Checks to the left.
Your Reply:



12:27PM on 10/07/2013
[link] says it all.

I also don't understand why anyone would want to be next Meryl Streep. Sure, she won a lot and has a lot of nominations, but everyone seems to forget that about 70% of the movies she is in, seriously suck and that she's often the only good thing about them.

I wanna see if Lawrence has staying power, a lot of people said that Winona Ryder was gonna be the absolute dominating force in the 21st century, didn't really happen, did it?
[link] says it all.

I also don't understand why anyone would want to be next Meryl Streep. Sure, she won a lot and has a lot of nominations, but everyone seems to forget that about 70% of the movies she is in, seriously suck and that she's often the only good thing about them.

I wanna see if Lawrence has staying power, a lot of people said that Winona Ryder was gonna be the absolute dominating force in the 21st century, didn't really happen, did it?
Your Reply:



12:17PM on 10/07/2013

Wrong.

No, seriously... that opinion is profoundly ill-conceived. First there was the idiot who thought Ryan Gosling's "Driver" was cooler than Steve McQueen as "Frank Bullitt." Now this?!? What the hell is going on around here lately?
No, seriously... that opinion is profoundly ill-conceived. First there was the idiot who thought Ryan Gosling's "Driver" was cooler than Steve McQueen as "Frank Bullitt." Now this?!? What the hell is going on around here lately?
Your Reply:



+3
11:54AM on 10/07/2013

Scarlett

Jennifer may well be the better actresses of the two...but I'm going with Scarlett every time...mainly coz of how she looked in that Iron Man 2 pic you got up there...and The Island. I wish I was good looking...and rich (and charming...and witty....and knew her)...Id have a chance for sure :o(
Jennifer may well be the better actresses of the two...but I'm going with Scarlett every time...mainly coz of how she looked in that Iron Man 2 pic you got up there...and The Island. I wish I was good looking...and rich (and charming...and witty....and knew her)...Id have a chance for sure :o(
Your Reply:



10:44AM on 10/07/2013

Jennifer

By a hair. She is just a more interesting actress than Scarlett. I must say that Scarlett has been improving over the last few years. As far as your Streep observation, I think Jessica Chastain is going to be the next Streep. Even though Jennifer is a great actress I think Chastain is going to do better things over time.
By a hair. She is just a more interesting actress than Scarlett. I must say that Scarlett has been improving over the last few years. As far as your Streep observation, I think Jessica Chastain is going to be the next Streep. Even though Jennifer is a great actress I think Chastain is going to do better things over time.
Your Reply:



10:41AM on 10/07/2013
Total agreement, Scarlett is cool but Jennifer is damn near perfection.
Total agreement, Scarlett is cool but Jennifer is damn near perfection.
Your Reply:



10:37AM on 10/07/2013

ScarJo should win every category.

You're kidding right? You clearly just rigged it so JLaw would win because if you were being honest ScarJo would have a check in each of those boxes.
You're kidding right? You clearly just rigged it so JLaw would win because if you were being honest ScarJo would have a check in each of those boxes.
Your Reply:



1:50PM on 10/07/2013
Sing it brotha
Sing it brotha
+0
10:18AM on 10/07/2013

Jennifer

Correct verdict. ScarJo is overrated.
Correct verdict. ScarJo is overrated.
Your Reply:



12:23AM on 10/08/2013
It doesn't make you a hypocrite to think one woman is more physically attractive than another, it just means you have particular tastes.

Lookswise, ScarJo is overrated, and that's my opinion. I say that because most people I know -- including a majority of folks on this site -- fall over themselves talking about how insanely beautiful she is. Esquire just named her Sexiest Woman Ever in History Blah Blah Blah or some such over-the-top title. Stuff like that makes me think she's overrated
It doesn't make you a hypocrite to think one woman is more physically attractive than another, it just means you have particular tastes.

Lookswise, ScarJo is overrated, and that's my opinion. I say that because most people I know -- including a majority of folks on this site -- fall over themselves talking about how insanely beautiful she is. Esquire just named her Sexiest Woman Ever in History Blah Blah Blah or some such over-the-top title. Stuff like that makes me think she's overrated when I look at her and I think she's just okay.

I wasn't aware there was a "cool thing" to love Jennifer Lawrence. But when I see pictures of both her and ScarJo side-by-side, then yeah I'm gonna pick Jennifer because she's better looking.

Perhaps you just think it's the "cool thing" to love Scarlett?
10:39AM on 10/07/2013
So is Jennifer Lawrence. I mean, it doesn't really bother me much, or make me like her less, but it's a bit hypocritical to say that Scarlett is overrated, and Jennifer Lawrence isn't. Especially considering it is now "the cool thing" to love Jennifer Lawrence, so there are now tons of people who love her just because they think it's uncool not to.
So is Jennifer Lawrence. I mean, it doesn't really bother me much, or make me like her less, but it's a bit hypocritical to say that Scarlett is overrated, and Jennifer Lawrence isn't. Especially considering it is now "the cool thing" to love Jennifer Lawrence, so there are now tons of people who love her just because they think it's uncool not to.
9:50AM on 10/07/2013
Fucking crazy talk.

Johansson should win just for having one of the sexiest mouths a woman has ever possessed.
Fucking crazy talk.

Johansson should win just for having one of the sexiest mouths a woman has ever possessed.
Your Reply:



9:33AM on 10/07/2013

A gigantic thumbs down on your career vote.

Just because Jennifer won an Academy Award, that doesn't mean she has a better career. And you do know that there's more to a career than just an Oscar win, right? In the years to come, Lawrence might have a better career, but it's too early to say that she does now...I mean, duh???
Johansson has also worked with more accomplished directors than Lawrence. To name a few, she's worked with Christopher Nolan, Woody Allen, Sofia Coppola, Jon Favreau, Cameron Crowe and Brian De Palma.

Hell, Anna
Just because Jennifer won an Academy Award, that doesn't mean she has a better career. And you do know that there's more to a career than just an Oscar win, right? In the years to come, Lawrence might have a better career, but it's too early to say that she does now...I mean, duh???
Johansson has also worked with more accomplished directors than Lawrence. To name a few, she's worked with Christopher Nolan, Woody Allen, Sofia Coppola, Jon Favreau, Cameron Crowe and Brian De Palma.

Hell, Anna Paquin won an Academy Award before she was even a teenager and her career isn't one for the future movie history books like you say Jennifer's is.
Your Reply:



1:56PM on 10/07/2013
Criker, are you refering to Jennifer head lining that awful ass Hungergames movie, im so sick off people jumping on "whats hot" i never cared for Jennifer.
Criker, are you refering to Jennifer head lining that awful ass Hungergames movie, im so sick off people jumping on "whats hot" i never cared for Jennifer.
10:54AM on 10/07/2013
Cricker...Are you serious? I mentioned the fact that she won an Oscar. And you do know that Johansson has done other films than The Avengers, right? And that there's more to a career than just winning an Oscar?

I mean, to name a few, she's worked with Christopher Nolan, Woody Allen, Sofia Coppola, Jon Favreau, Cameron Crowe and Brian De Palma.

Matt Damon has never won an Oscar for acting, but he's worked with almost all the great directors, but since he hasn't won one, does that mean
Cricker...Are you serious? I mentioned the fact that she won an Oscar. And you do know that Johansson has done other films than The Avengers, right? And that there's more to a career than just winning an Oscar?

I mean, to name a few, she's worked with Christopher Nolan, Woody Allen, Sofia Coppola, Jon Favreau, Cameron Crowe and Brian De Palma.

Matt Damon has never won an Oscar for acting, but he's worked with almost all the great directors, but since he hasn't won one, does that mean that Adrien Brody has had a better career since he won one, or that every actor that has only won one had a better career?
10:06AM on 10/07/2013
yeah lets not forget that she actually won an Oscar, was nominated for another and headlined a blockbuster movie without being a fifth wheel who had less than 20 minutes screen time in the Avengers
yeah lets not forget that she actually won an Oscar, was nominated for another and headlined a blockbuster movie without being a fifth wheel who had less than 20 minutes screen time in the Avengers
8:33AM on 10/07/2013
This is too unfair. They're both my top hotties! ScarJo has the more vixen, sex goddess thing going down while J-Law has the uber girl next door, marry her kind of vibe. I choose both!
This is too unfair. They're both my top hotties! ScarJo has the more vixen, sex goddess thing going down while J-Law has the uber girl next door, marry her kind of vibe. I choose both!
Your Reply:



+20
8:00AM on 10/07/2013

Seriously, Jennifer?!

bullshit, Scarlett is the better choice hands down. how the hell do you have Hotness and Beauty as two seperate catagories, maybe its me, but those are the same to me.
bullshit, Scarlett is the better choice hands down. how the hell do you have Hotness and Beauty as two seperate catagories, maybe its me, but those are the same to me.
Your Reply:



2:00PM on 10/07/2013
dont be a dumbass Bridgeburner
dont be a dumbass Bridgeburner
11:18AM on 10/07/2013
@cricker...You do know that there's more to a career than just winning an Oscar, right? Johansson has worked with more accomplished directors than Lawrence. To name a few, she's worked with Christopher Nolan, Woody Allen, Sofia Coppola, Jon Favreau, Cameron Crowe and Brian De Palma.

Matt Damon has never won an Oscar for acting, but he's worked with almost all the great directors, but since he hasn't won one, does that mean that Adrien Brody has had a better career since he won one, or that
@cricker...You do know that there's more to a career than just winning an Oscar, right? Johansson has worked with more accomplished directors than Lawrence. To name a few, she's worked with Christopher Nolan, Woody Allen, Sofia Coppola, Jon Favreau, Cameron Crowe and Brian De Palma.

Matt Damon has never won an Oscar for acting, but he's worked with almost all the great directors, but since he hasn't won one, does that mean that Adrien Brody has had a better career since he won one, or that every actor that has only won one has had a better career?
10:30AM on 10/07/2013
I might agree with you about Scarlett Johansson, but how in the hell can you think there is no difference between hotness and beauty? Next are you going to say that cute and sexy are the same thing?
I might agree with you about Scarlett Johansson, but how in the hell can you think there is no difference between hotness and beauty? Next are you going to say that cute and sexy are the same thing?
10:08AM on 10/07/2013
yes jennifer. Yah know the career accomplishments much younger in age, that red dress at the oscars, oh winning an oscar too and nominated for a 2nd, headliner in her own blockbuster movie
yes jennifer. Yah know the career accomplishments much younger in age, that red dress at the oscars, oh winning an oscar too and nominated for a 2nd, headliner in her own blockbuster movie
6:16AM on 10/07/2013
Scarlett's sexier but Jennifer Lawrence seems like she'd be a hell of a lot more fun to hang around with. Also, hot damn, that photo of J-Law seated in the bikini.
Scarlett's sexier but Jennifer Lawrence seems like she'd be a hell of a lot more fun to hang around with. Also, hot damn, that photo of J-Law seated in the bikini.
Your Reply:



6:15AM on 10/07/2013
Career-wise, Jennifer Lawrence might be the winner but Scarlett Johansson is the Winner in my book.
Career-wise, Jennifer Lawrence might be the winner but Scarlett Johansson is the Winner in my book.
Your Reply:



10:06PM on 10/07/2013
Thanks, dude!
Thanks, dude!
10:09AM on 10/07/2013
ur comment said it all, her career is better and she is much younger, that's kinda all this is about. Hell if just being hot was a qualification Megan Fox would be a star rather than being in TMNT
ur comment said it all, her career is better and she is much younger, that's kinda all this is about. Hell if just being hot was a qualification Megan Fox would be a star rather than being in TMNT
-8
5:54AM on 10/07/2013

Are you kidding me?

should be a sweep by Lawrence. Johansson wins beauty? So you tell me that a young Christopher Walken is more pretty than Jennifer Lawrence? HAHAHAHA, yeah ok. Anyone who says ScarJo does NOT look just like a young Walken has not looked it up. Shut your mouth and go do some googling. She DOES, it is funny and disturbing at the same time. Lawrence for the landslide victory.
should be a sweep by Lawrence. Johansson wins beauty? So you tell me that a young Christopher Walken is more pretty than Jennifer Lawrence? HAHAHAHA, yeah ok. Anyone who says ScarJo does NOT look just like a young Walken has not looked it up. Shut your mouth and go do some googling. She DOES, it is funny and disturbing at the same time. Lawrence for the landslide victory.
Your Reply:



4:54AM on 10/07/2013

Scarlett Johansson

Scarlett is one of the great beauties in Hollywood and a damn fine actress as well. Jennifer is certainly beautiful but even she isn't in Scarlett's league.
Scarlett is one of the great beauties in Hollywood and a damn fine actress as well. Jennifer is certainly beautiful but even she isn't in Scarlett's league.
Your Reply:



11:21AM on 10/07/2013
@cricker...You do know that there's more to a career than just winning an Oscar, right? Johansson has worked with more accomplished directors than Lawrence. To name a few, she's worked with Christopher Nolan, Woody Allen, Sofia Coppola, Jon Favreau, Cameron Crowe and Brian De Palma.
Matt Damon has never won an Oscar for acting, but he's worked with almost all the great directors, but since he hasn't won one, does that mean that Adrien Brody has had a better career since he won one, or that
@cricker...You do know that there's more to a career than just winning an Oscar, right? Johansson has worked with more accomplished directors than Lawrence. To name a few, she's worked with Christopher Nolan, Woody Allen, Sofia Coppola, Jon Favreau, Cameron Crowe and Brian De Palma.
Matt Damon has never won an Oscar for acting, but he's worked with almost all the great directors, but since he hasn't won one, does that mean that Adrien Brody has had a better career since he won one, or that every actor that has only won one has had a better career?
10:11AM on 10/07/2013
I know johannson is a career minor leaguer when it comes to acting talent as opposed to Lawrence's 2 oscar noms by the age of 21
I know johannson is a career minor leaguer when it comes to acting talent as opposed to Lawrence's 2 oscar noms by the age of 21

Featured Youtube Videos

Views and Counting

Movie Hottie Of The Week

More

Latest Hot Celebrity Pictures

More
christina-milianchristina-milianvictoria-justicevictoria-justice