Latest Movie Hotties Headlines

Face Off: Emmy Rossum vs. Katharine McPhee

09.07.2015by: Droz

It was another dead heat between Alice Eve and Natalie Dormer after last week's Face Off was all said and done. I guess I need to put together a ridiculously lopsided duo that will get you guys on one side or another.

I doubt think this week's match-up will be the one to inspire a clean sweep for either side. After all, birthday girl Emmy Rossum (who turns 29 this week) and Katharine McPhee are doing fairly similar things with their time in the spotlight. They're both singers, both movie and TV stars. On that last front, they've both got their own popular shows, Shameless and Scorpion, the latter starting its second season in a few days. They're also both powerfully hot women, fond of demonstrating that fact as often as possible. Seems like it's just a matter of deciding which one does the same thing better. So, who you got?

Beauty

I'm totally smitten with a number of Emmy's great features. I could make a big list of all the things I love about her. Right up at the top of that list would be her big, brown, doe eyes. I have such a terrible weakness for women with eyes like hers. They are true windows to everything she's feeling or thinking. I could lose hours and hours of time staring into eyes like those.

Katharine is one of those women you run across from time to time who really needs to be seen in motion. 2-dimensional still images just can't do her beauty justice. Her true sweetheart nature comes out strongest when she's animated. I still don't understand why or how that lack of dimensionality works against some, but it's an issue I see in her. Emmy, on the other hand, is fantastic however you can get her.

Body

This category is a big reason why I thought these two would make for a good Face Off. As a dedicated ass man, I'm naturally pulled in by the power of Emmy's fantastic backside. It's just about perfect where asses go. Put that fine butt together with the rest of Emmy's long, lean, yet bountifully curvy body and you get one of the finer feminine packages walking around today.

Katharine's physical assets are probably 90% of the reason why I even know who she is and why I rank her so highly among the crowds of fine women in entertainment today. Like Emmy, much of that 90% comes down to her ass. Look at that thing. Look how it curves out so perfectly under that dress. It's like ripe produce on the shelf. My mouth waters just looking at her butt. I would literally worship that thing.

Hotness

Emmy is almost too pretty to be as hot as she is. It's not often someone so sweet also stars on a TV show where she has dudes going down on her in some of the best sex scenes ever. I choose Emmy here not only because she is so sweet and so frequently getting down to sexy hiijinks both on her show and elsewhere, but also for the enthusiasm she shows for such undertakings. Emmy seems to get off on being a hottie. Which makes her even hotter.

Katharine is plenty hot. I've seen her make expert use of her hotness several times over the years. Sometimes she does so without even having to try. But as is usually the case here, it's all about the temperature at which two Face Off competitors reach their hotness. Emmy gets my vote on this because she takes things to a higher degree. Were Katharine getting down to the kind of stuff Emmy does on her show, I would totally tie this category up.

Career

Emmy seems laid back and low key with her career choices. She had her flirtations with big budget blockbusters once, but nowadays a small movie every once in awhile seems to do. I recently enjoyed Emmy in COMET. Kind of a strange movie, but interesting. Even if the movie isn't so good, Emmy is usually one of the better things about it. And of course, there's Shameless, which continues to be her main claim to fame. It's a show I've usually enjoyed, with its various ups and downs. That's once again due in large part to Emmy. I think I just like to watch her, no matter what she's up to.

Katharine has a lovely singing voice. Unfortunately she chose to demonstrate that on American Idol, a show which is one of those bane of my existence things. So we we didn't get off on the right footing there. I was mildly amused by her Scorpion show, but I don't think that's targeted at me either. In fact, most of her movies and shows really aren't for me. That's not her fault. That's just how it is.

Emmy

Two great hotties here, both worthy choices. But I'm going with Emmy. She's got so many of the great things I love in a woman. I could never deny her.

Just one man's opinion. What are your thoughts?

RECOMMENDED MOVIE NEWS

MORE FUN FROM AROUND THE WEB

Drool Back
Not registered? Sign-up!
Or

11:48PM on 09/09/2015

Emmy Rossum for me

Admittedly, Katharine McPhee's association with American Idol makes me shudder, along with her appearance in a particularly heinous Barbie DVD that I was on when visiting a friend's place (he has a 4-year-old daughter). But yes, I consider Emmy more attractive and more talented.
Admittedly, Katharine McPhee's association with American Idol makes me shudder, along with her appearance in a particularly heinous Barbie DVD that I was on when visiting a friend's place (he has a 4-year-old daughter). But yes, I consider Emmy more attractive and more talented.
Your Reply:



+0
12:03AM on 09/09/2015

Rossum....

Not only is she hotter and better looking, she is totally cool with getting naked and even doing the naughtier side of it on TV.
Not only is she hotter and better looking, she is totally cool with getting naked and even doing the naughtier side of it on TV.
Your Reply:



4:36AM on 09/08/2015

Emmy

But Katherine ain't that bad looking either!
But Katherine ain't that bad looking either!
Your Reply:



+0
8:21PM on 09/07/2015

Emmy

Crazy close battle but Kat loses 5 points for being associated with Idol. This gives Emmy the win.
Crazy close battle but Kat loses 5 points for being associated with Idol. This gives Emmy the win.
Your Reply:



2:41PM on 09/07/2015
Hardest Face/Off for me, I love both of these women. Emmy edges out Katharine simply because her singing is awe inducing.
Hardest Face/Off for me, I love both of these women. Emmy edges out Katharine simply because her singing is awe inducing.
Your Reply:



11:45AM on 09/07/2015
Agree with Emmy. And yes, American idol is a huge downgrade for me as well.
Agree with Emmy. And yes, American idol is a huge downgrade for me as well.
Your Reply:



+0
11:37AM on 09/07/2015

Kat

Kat for me. Emmy is cute, but definitely Kat for me.
Kat for me. Emmy is cute, but definitely Kat for me.
Your Reply:



9:54AM on 09/07/2015

Emmy

no brainer for me, Emmy has become such a flawless, classy beauty - she is also a very talented actor
no brainer for me, Emmy has become such a flawless, classy beauty - she is also a very talented actor
Your Reply:



9:51AM on 09/07/2015

Emmy

Easy choice this week.
Easy choice this week.
Your Reply:



+0
9:36AM on 09/07/2015

Almost a tie...

... but I pick Emmy.
... but I pick Emmy.
Your Reply:



8:35AM on 09/07/2015

Kat

Kat McPhee is way hotter than Emmy Rossum IMO
Kat McPhee is way hotter than Emmy Rossum IMO
Your Reply:



8:02AM on 09/07/2015

Emmy most definitely.

Undeniable sex appeal.

Katharine seems kinda vanilla. Also, when she was on Hollywood Game Night, there was a question regarding NASA rovers and she didn't know what a NASA rover was.
Undeniable sex appeal.

Katharine seems kinda vanilla. Also, when she was on Hollywood Game Night, there was a question regarding NASA rovers and she didn't know what a NASA rover was.
Your Reply:



7:43AM on 09/07/2015
Couldn't agree with this more. I've always thought Emmy was an underrated hottie and seeing her in Shameless shows what a great actress she is as well.
Couldn't agree with this more. I've always thought Emmy was an underrated hottie and seeing her in Shameless shows what a great actress she is as well.
Your Reply:



7:11AM on 09/07/2015
Booo Katharine all the way!
Booo Katharine all the way!
Your Reply:



Featured Youtube Videos

Views and Counting

Movie Hottie Of The Week

More

Latest Hot Celebrity Pictures

More
blake-livelyblake-livelyblake-livelyblake-lively